Come As You Are Inn

Hotel Checkout

Reservations:

+1 (888) 385-8465

‌

From

$558

Reservations:

+1 (888) 385-8465

Hotel Highlights

Welcome to the Come As You Are Inn, where your comfort is our priority, and good times are always on the menu! Nestled just 0.2mi from the vibrant heart of Sayville, New York, this charming bed and breakfast is the perfect getaway for adults seeking a unique blend of relaxation and entertainment. Start your adventure with a delightful breakfast included in your stay, and don’t forget to explore our beautifully manicured garden or enjoy live music performances that set the perfect ambiance.

Rooms

Double Room with Private Bathroom in Come As You Are Inn

Show 4 photos

1 Queen Size Bed

150 sqft

Double Room, Private Bathroom

Private Bathroom

Bathtub

Washing machine

Minibar

Deluxe Queen Suite in Come As You Are Inn

Show 3 photos

1 Queen Size Bed

150 sqft

Deluxe Suite

Private Bathroom

Bathtub

Minibar

Coffee machine

Family, Pool View

Discover More

Our inn offers everything you need for a peaceful retreat (adults only, please!), including free Wi-Fi and a streaming service—think Netflix and chill in comfy surroundings! After a day of exploration, unwind in your non-smoking room equipped with air conditioning and extra-long beds for those who love to stretch out. Bring your car and take advantage of our complimentary on-site parking, because who doesn't love a good deal?

Property building, Bed in Come As You Are Inn

Experience the Best

With 37 glowing reviews and prices starting at just $558, Come As You Are Inn has quickly become a beloved spot for travelers seeking a fun, relaxing escape. Whether you're indulging in a luxurious bath or enjoying a serene picnic in our outdoor space, our friendly staff is here to ensure every moment of your stay is memorable. So, pack your bags and let the adventure begin at the Come As You Are Inn, located at 59 Greene Avenue—where every visit feels just like home!

Plan Your Stay

Imagine waking up in a cozy 151 sqft Double Room with Private Bathroom or a luxurious Deluxe Queen Suite, where you can spread out in your plush surroundings. Each room at the Come As You Are Inn oozes charm with its welcoming ambiance and is designed exclusively for two adults. After a refreshing slumber, step into your serene space and bask in the warm morning light filtering through the windows. Whether you prefer snuggling up in a luxurious blanket or diving into some binge-worthy shows, you’ll find every stay just feels indulgent.

Amenities

Snorkeling

Outdoor swimming pool

Free Private Parking

Adults only

Free wifi

Streaming service (like Netflix)

Golf course

Air conditioning

Pool

Outdoor, All ages

Seasonal, Salt water, Shallow end

Ari and Mark made me feel very comfortable and welcome. I was looking for a place to stay during a wedding so I wouldn't have to travel back home late Saturday night. I decided to make it a weekend so came out Friday and stayed til Sunday, It was 4 minutes from the wedding venue. I liked the overall feel of the house. Comfy, very clean, well decorated. My own bathroom with a big soaker tub and plenty of room in the bathroom itself. You can lock your room and bathroom if you like- key for each. I didn't feel the need but you can. Being able to adjust the room air conditioner to my liking is a plus (2nd floor- I believe the first floor has central air). Comfortable sitting choices in my room- soft chair & love seat. I found out about a fine arts show in the Hamptons because one of the artist exhibitors was staying also so I went to the show on Sunday instead of heading right home. The pool was big and beautiful though I didn't use it- I did notice that it got some shade at times. Sometimes I notice little things- the items in the room fridge were very fairly priced- not high hotel prices. Came in handy cuz I got leg cramps when I got back from wedding and hooray- tonic water in my fridge. Mark and Ari put time and attention into making the continental breakfast memorable and different each day. I'm taking this much time to review because when owners put this much effort in- they deserve it. Ari & I also spent a lot of time just talking. I hope to return here again.

Star

Out of all the accommodations I booked during my travels in the United States, this has been the most exceptional one. From the moment the door opened, I felt at home and really, really welcome. The landlords are amazing people, who will go out of their way to make their guest feel comfortable. I actually spent hours chatting with them instead of exploring the area, because they were just so interesting and easy to talk to. In addition to amazing conversation, I even got treated to a piano recital in the evening. So while Sayville may not be the most thrilling place you could think of, I would consider coming back just to stay at the "Come as you are Inn" again. Also, I suspect, it may be difficult to find another B&B with a great cook and a great pianist under the same roof. Breakfast was lovely, the bedroom and bathroom were great, there was not a thing to complain about in that house. I got offered lifts, I was allowed to do some laundry (mine, not theirs :)) - things that aren't for granted and which I very much appreciated. The B&B is within walking distance to the train station, if you don't have a car. It's also just a few minutes' walk to the Main Street with shops, cafés and restaurants. There's a big supermarket nearby. One could even walk to the ferry terminal to Fire Island within 20-40 minutes (depending on your pace). My stay at the "Come as you are Inn" has been an extraordinary experience and I'm very glad I stopped there.

Nora

I was greeted by the hosts Ari and Mark who were warm and welcoming.A most charming couple. They are good conversationalists and you could spend hours talking with them. They also have a great sense of humor. Its LGBTQ friendly but anyone will feel welcome here. The inn was quaint, charming and very clean. I loved my Tammy room. Bed was firm and comfortable. Bathroom was spacious. I loved the breakfasts also. The Continental breakfast is free: Hard-boiled eggs, yogurt, granola and the most delicious baked goods made by Ari. If you want eggs and bacon, it's extra but fair. During the Summer, the backyard is the crown jewel of the inn. A luxurious heated pool, fire pit and another sitting area. I was here for a music festival and wish I had more time to spend by the beautiful pool. Also to explore the area. Sayville is a lovely and quaint little village with many dining options. The ferries to Fire Island are just a hop away. I would love to come back and explore that. I really look forward to my next visit!

Janine

Ari and Mark are wonderful hosts. They went above and beyond to ensure our comfort. They got us the Fire Island ferry schedule and even offered to drive us to the ferry terminal. The room and soaking tub were very comfortable. A delicious breakfast was provided each morning with yogurt, fresh berries and a home made bread basket with four different delicious breads. Ari offered to cook eggs and bacon too. Mark and Ari are great company and we enjoyed many conversations with them. We highly recommend their inn. We will definitely stay there again if in the area.

Carmel

My sister and I really enjoyed our time here. Ari and Mark were so accommodating. They felt like family immediately. In the morning Ari baked items for breakfast (even early for us since we were on a set schedule )and Mark drove us to the airport so we could pick up our rental car. The bnb is in a good location, walking distance to Sayville's Main St, the library and the train station. The rooms are clean and beautiful. The bed and linens were really comfortable and the private bathroom had a massive tub in it.

Haley

Ari and Mark made me feel very comfortable and welcome. I was looking for a place to stay during a wedding so I wouldn't have to travel back home late Saturday night. I decided to make it a weekend so came out Friday and stayed til Sunday, It was 4 minutes from the wedding venue. I liked the overall feel of the house. Comfy, very clean, well decorated. My own bathroom with a big soaker tub and plenty of room in the bathroom itself. You can lock your room and bathroom if you like- key for each. I didn't feel the need but you can. Being able to adjust the room air conditioner to my liking is a plus (2nd floor- I believe the first floor has central air). Comfortable sitting choices in my room- soft chair & love seat. I found out about a fine arts show in the Hamptons because one of the artist exhibitors was staying also so I went to the show on Sunday instead of heading right home. The pool was big and beautiful though I didn't use it- I did notice that it got some shade at times. Sometimes I notice little things- the items in the room fridge were very fairly priced- not high hotel prices. Came in handy cuz I got leg cramps when I got back from wedding and hooray- tonic water in my fridge. Mark and Ari put time and attention into making the continental breakfast memorable and different each day. I'm taking this much time to review because when owners put this much effort in- they deserve it. Ari & I also spent a lot of time just talking. I hope to return here again.

Star

Out of all the accommodations I booked during my travels in the United States, this has been the most exceptional one. From the moment the door opened, I felt at home and really, really welcome. The landlords are amazing people, who will go out of their way to make their guest feel comfortable. I actually spent hours chatting with them instead of exploring the area, because they were just so interesting and easy to talk to. In addition to amazing conversation, I even got treated to a piano recital in the evening. So while Sayville may not be the most thrilling place you could think of, I would consider coming back just to stay at the "Come as you are Inn" again. Also, I suspect, it may be difficult to find another B&B with a great cook and a great pianist under the same roof. Breakfast was lovely, the bedroom and bathroom were great, there was not a thing to complain about in that house. I got offered lifts, I was allowed to do some laundry (mine, not theirs :)) - things that aren't for granted and which I very much appreciated. The B&B is within walking distance to the train station, if you don't have a car. It's also just a few minutes' walk to the Main Street with shops, cafés and restaurants. There's a big supermarket nearby. One could even walk to the ferry terminal to Fire Island within 20-40 minutes (depending on your pace). My stay at the "Come as you are Inn" has been an extraordinary experience and I'm very glad I stopped there.

Nora

I was greeted by the hosts Ari and Mark who were warm and welcoming.A most charming couple. They are good conversationalists and you could spend hours talking with them. They also have a great sense of humor. Its LGBTQ friendly but anyone will feel welcome here. The inn was quaint, charming and very clean. I loved my Tammy room. Bed was firm and comfortable. Bathroom was spacious. I loved the breakfasts also. The Continental breakfast is free: Hard-boiled eggs, yogurt, granola and the most delicious baked goods made by Ari. If you want eggs and bacon, it's extra but fair. During the Summer, the backyard is the crown jewel of the inn. A luxurious heated pool, fire pit and another sitting area. I was here for a music festival and wish I had more time to spend by the beautiful pool. Also to explore the area. Sayville is a lovely and quaint little village with many dining options. The ferries to Fire Island are just a hop away. I would love to come back and explore that. I really look forward to my next visit!

Janine

Ari and Mark are wonderful hosts. They went above and beyond to ensure our comfort. They got us the Fire Island ferry schedule and even offered to drive us to the ferry terminal. The room and soaking tub were very comfortable. A delicious breakfast was provided each morning with yogurt, fresh berries and a home made bread basket with four different delicious breads. Ari offered to cook eggs and bacon too. Mark and Ari are great company and we enjoyed many conversations with them. We highly recommend their inn. We will definitely stay there again if in the area.

Carmel

My sister and I really enjoyed our time here. Ari and Mark were so accommodating. They felt like family immediately. In the morning Ari baked items for breakfast (even early for us since we were on a set schedule )and Mark drove us to the airport so we could pick up our rental car. The bnb is in a good location, walking distance to Sayville's Main St, the library and the train station. The rooms are clean and beautiful. The bed and linens were really comfortable and the private bathroom had a massive tub in it.

Haley

Ari and Mark made me feel very comfortable and welcome. I was looking for a place to stay during a wedding so I wouldn't have to travel back home late Saturday night. I decided to make it a weekend so came out Friday and stayed til Sunday, It was 4 minutes from the wedding venue. I liked the overall feel of the house. Comfy, very clean, well decorated. My own bathroom with a big soaker tub and plenty of room in the bathroom itself. You can lock your room and bathroom if you like- key for each. I didn't feel the need but you can. Being able to adjust the room air conditioner to my liking is a plus (2nd floor- I believe the first floor has central air). Comfortable sitting choices in my room- soft chair & love seat. I found out about a fine arts show in the Hamptons because one of the artist exhibitors was staying also so I went to the show on Sunday instead of heading right home. The pool was big and beautiful though I didn't use it- I did notice that it got some shade at times. Sometimes I notice little things- the items in the room fridge were very fairly priced- not high hotel prices. Came in handy cuz I got leg cramps when I got back from wedding and hooray- tonic water in my fridge. Mark and Ari put time and attention into making the continental breakfast memorable and different each day. I'm taking this much time to review because when owners put this much effort in- they deserve it. Ari & I also spent a lot of time just talking. I hope to return here again.

Star

Out of all the accommodations I booked during my travels in the United States, this has been the most exceptional one. From the moment the door opened, I felt at home and really, really welcome. The landlords are amazing people, who will go out of their way to make their guest feel comfortable. I actually spent hours chatting with them instead of exploring the area, because they were just so interesting and easy to talk to. In addition to amazing conversation, I even got treated to a piano recital in the evening. So while Sayville may not be the most thrilling place you could think of, I would consider coming back just to stay at the "Come as you are Inn" again. Also, I suspect, it may be difficult to find another B&B with a great cook and a great pianist under the same roof. Breakfast was lovely, the bedroom and bathroom were great, there was not a thing to complain about in that house. I got offered lifts, I was allowed to do some laundry (mine, not theirs :)) - things that aren't for granted and which I very much appreciated. The B&B is within walking distance to the train station, if you don't have a car. It's also just a few minutes' walk to the Main Street with shops, cafés and restaurants. There's a big supermarket nearby. One could even walk to the ferry terminal to Fire Island within 20-40 minutes (depending on your pace). My stay at the "Come as you are Inn" has been an extraordinary experience and I'm very glad I stopped there.

Nora

I was greeted by the hosts Ari and Mark who were warm and welcoming.A most charming couple. They are good conversationalists and you could spend hours talking with them. They also have a great sense of humor. Its LGBTQ friendly but anyone will feel welcome here. The inn was quaint, charming and very clean. I loved my Tammy room. Bed was firm and comfortable. Bathroom was spacious. I loved the breakfasts also. The Continental breakfast is free: Hard-boiled eggs, yogurt, granola and the most delicious baked goods made by Ari. If you want eggs and bacon, it's extra but fair. During the Summer, the backyard is the crown jewel of the inn. A luxurious heated pool, fire pit and another sitting area. I was here for a music festival and wish I had more time to spend by the beautiful pool. Also to explore the area. Sayville is a lovely and quaint little village with many dining options. The ferries to Fire Island are just a hop away. I would love to come back and explore that. I really look forward to my next visit!

Janine

Ari and Mark are wonderful hosts. They went above and beyond to ensure our comfort. They got us the Fire Island ferry schedule and even offered to drive us to the ferry terminal. The room and soaking tub were very comfortable. A delicious breakfast was provided each morning with yogurt, fresh berries and a home made bread basket with four different delicious breads. Ari offered to cook eggs and bacon too. Mark and Ari are great company and we enjoyed many conversations with them. We highly recommend their inn. We will definitely stay there again if in the area.

Carmel

My sister and I really enjoyed our time here. Ari and Mark were so accommodating. They felt like family immediately. In the morning Ari baked items for breakfast (even early for us since we were on a set schedule )and Mark drove us to the airport so we could pick up our rental car. The bnb is in a good location, walking distance to Sayville's Main St, the library and the train station. The rooms are clean and beautiful. The bed and linens were really comfortable and the private bathroom had a massive tub in it.

Haley

Location

59 Greene Avenue, Sayville, NY 11782, United States

Reservations:

+1 (888) 385-8465